Page 1 of 17

Shipbucket Ranting thread

Posted: February 20th, 2012, 6:02 pm
by Colosseum
All you silly children with your fancy shading and torpedoes being displayed... MConrads would shake his head!

Re: Italy's Primadonnas - Part Deux - De la Penne & Mimbelli

Posted: February 20th, 2012, 6:14 pm
by heuhen
Colosseum wrote:All you silly children with your fancy shading and torpedoes being displayed... MConrads would shake his head!
and I the Norwegian one will watch!

Re: Italy's Primadonnas - Part Deux - De la Penne & Mimbelli

Posted: February 20th, 2012, 7:07 pm
by Bombhead
Colosseum wrote:All you silly children with your fancy shading and torpedoes being displayed... MConrads would shake his head!
I think MConrads would be quite happy that times and standards move on and indeed improve. ;)

Re: Italy's Primadonnas - Part Deux - De la Penne & Mimbelli

Posted: February 20th, 2012, 7:12 pm
by Colosseum
:/ Suit yourselves.

I believe his method of drawing ships outshines even the nicest new ships when executed properly.

Re: Italy's Primadonnas - Part Deux - De la Penne & Mimbelli

Posted: February 20th, 2012, 8:54 pm
by bezobrazov
Well, I'm sorry that you so disapprove of my attempt at an upgrade, Ian.

Yes, it would be very interesting to know what MConrad might have to say.

Now, i can see one great benefit if we're showing the weapons types including torpedoes: there's been classes of ships with stern- and bow-mounted torpedo tubes; sometimes firing a different torpedo compared to the 'normal' outfit carried. Such types were the German Type 101A and the Audace-class before the 1980s.The italian Maestrales (which i actually have an upgrade of!) still have stern-mounted ASuW torpedo sytem (553 mm)!

Whether to actually place them adjacent to the missiles is a wholly different issue, which i refrain from commenting!

Re: Italy's Primadonnas - Part Deux - De la Penne & Mimbelli

Posted: February 20th, 2012, 8:56 pm
by bezobrazov
...and Ian, to label me a child is not exactly appropriate. I am 46 and have been dealing with ships and naval matters for the past 34 years or so... so I do believe I may have a few years advantage on you still... (said in all friendliness! :) )

Re: Italy's Primadonnas - Part Deux - De la Penne & Mimbelli

Posted: February 20th, 2012, 9:24 pm
by SHIPDUDE
Logically torpedoes should be displayed beneath the ship!

Re: Italy's Primadonnas - Part Deux - De la Penne & Mimbelli

Posted: February 20th, 2012, 9:34 pm
by Colosseum
Image

Re: Italy's Primadonnas - Part Deux - De la Penne & Mimbelli

Posted: February 20th, 2012, 9:50 pm
by Colosseum
Well, I'm sorry that you so disapprove of my attempt at an upgrade, Ian.
I'm not talking specifically about you but rather about everyone in general. And do note that I said "when executed properly", not "all the time".
Now, i can see one great benefit if we're showing the weapons types including torpedoes: there's been classes of ships with stern- and bow-mounted torpedo tubes; sometimes firing a different torpedo compared to the 'normal' outfit carried. Such types were the German Type 101A and the Audace-class before the 1980s.The italian Maestrales (which i actually have an upgrade of!) still have stern-mounted ASuW torpedo sytem (553 mm)!
I have nothing against showing torpedoes.
Whether to actually place them adjacent to the missiles is a wholly different issue, which i refrain from commenting!
If anything I prefer a system placing torpedoes below the ship for clarity's sake.
...and Ian, to label me a child is not exactly appropriate. I am 46 and have been dealing with ships and naval matters for the past 34 years or so... so I do believe I may have a few years advantage on you still... (said in all friendliness! :) )
That's fine and dandy but I've been drawing ships in this format longer than 90% of this board and I believe I can speak with some authority on style changes and whatnot. As I've stated before, how you guys draw your ships doesn't matter to me... I was just making a joke. :P Especially now that I'm no longer part of the staff here... what others do no longer concerns me! As far as I'm concerned I will continue to draw the "old" way and you guys can do whatever you want!

Re: Italy's Primadonnas - Part Deux - De la Penne & Mimbelli

Posted: February 20th, 2012, 10:51 pm
by BrockPaine
Colosseum wrote:Image
Sir, request permission to laugh, sir!