Page 1 of 3

Queen Elisabeth Class Battleship

Posted: May 13th, 2021, 12:47 pm
by Karle94
Here is the lineup of the entire Queen Elisabeth class from 1914 up until the early-mid 30s. I wanted to do these before starting on the second rebuilds as some of them are approaching the WW2 era, and I wanted to nail down the ships before their appearance starts to wildly differ, for the sake of speed and efficiency.

HMS Queen Elizabeth in 1914:
Image

HMS Queen Elizabeth in 1915:
Image

HMS Queen Elizabeth in 1916:
Image

HMS Queen Elizabeth in 1918:
Image

HMS Queen Elizabeth in 1920:
Image

HMS Queen Elizabeth in 1926:
Image

HMS Queen Elizabeth in 1928:
Image

HMS Queen Elizabeth in 1936:
Image

HMS Queen Elizabeth in 1941:
Image

HMS Warspite in 1915:
Image

HMS Warspite in 1918:
Image

HMS Warspite in 1919:
Image

HMS Warspite in 1924:
Image

HMS Warspite in 1933:
Image

HMS Warspite in 1938:
Image

HMS Valiant in 1915:
Image

HMS Valiant in 1918:
Image

HMS Valiant in 1925:
Image

HMS Valiant in 1927:
Image

HMS Valiant in 1930:
Image

HMS Valiant in 1939:
Image

HMS Barham in 1915:
Image

HMS Barham in 1918:
Image

HMS Barham in 1920:
Image

HMS Barham in 1925:
Image

HMS Barham in 1928:
Image

HMS Barham in 1937:
Image

HMS Malaya in 1916:
Image

HMS Malaya in 1919:
Image

HMS Malaya in 1928:
Image

HMS Malaya in 1931:
Image

HMS Malaya in 1937:
Image

Re: Queen Elisabeth Class Battleship

Posted: May 13th, 2021, 2:10 pm
by emperor_andreas
Incredible job! Can't wait to see the later versions! Are you planning on showcasing the Royal Sovereign-class like this as well?

Re: Queen Elisabeth Class Battleship

Posted: May 13th, 2021, 3:42 pm
by Armoured man
They are very nice drawings indeed, although I feel that they look some what unfinished and very bland looking, another thing that someone pointed out to me on the discord is that there is a distinct lack of overhang shading in many areas with the biggest examples being the turrets.

Re: Queen Elisabeth Class Battleship

Posted: May 13th, 2021, 4:06 pm
by Karle94
emperor_andreas wrote: May 13th, 2021, 2:10 pm Incredible job! Can't wait to see the later versions! Are you planning on showcasing the Royal Sovereign-class like this as well?
I do intend to do that, yes.

Re: Queen Elisabeth Class Battleship

Posted: May 13th, 2021, 7:11 pm
by kvasius
Good work on portraying these.
I've been planning to do (more like redo) a series on Warspite ever since i drew the 1942 all the way back in 2018 (...it has a lot of small and not so small issues now that i look back at it), but I never got to actually get myself properly on track. The whole idea got lost somewhere along the line, despite the fact I've went out of my way to get some of the best publications about the ship in question out there.
Since i haven't got to draw it, might as well help with pointing out some inconsistencies and errors.

1) I'm struggling to see the 3-pdr guns located near the conning tower, removed in 1929 (the right plan, replaced by hawker reel in blue lining).
Image
2)According to plans J9807 and J9808 (HMS Malaya as fitted with 1924/1929 refits drawn over) and info from Brown's Battleship Warspite, Malaya's bulge extended 12ft further forward than that of Warspite.
Warspite had flying-off platforms fitted to its B and X turrets in the end of 1919 (here over the turret and the barrels) and kept in a shape until the major reconstruction of 1934-1937; as well as the fact that the sternwalk was fitted, not removed in 1923.
Image
3)There might be some smaller issues about the foremast and 15in gun control tower, however, on the first glance i'm not so sure about that, so i'll leave the detailed research on that to you.
Image
Image

All scans taken from Robert Brown's "Battleship Warspite: detailed in original builders' plans", 2017; ISBN 978 1 5267 1937 9; of which i'm a proud owner of.

In any case, these drawings show great effort put into them, so it would be a waste to have them bogged down by these small oversights and minor issues. Good luck on continuing these series. :D

Re: Queen Elisabeth Class Battleship

Posted: May 13th, 2021, 10:16 pm
by heuhen
awesome work

Re: Queen Elisabeth Class Battleship

Posted: May 13th, 2021, 10:27 pm
by emperor_andreas
emperor_andreas wrote: May 13th, 2021, 2:10 pmIncredible job! Can't wait to see the later versions! Are you planning on showcasing the Royal Sovereign-class like this as well?
Karle94 wrote: May 13th, 2021, 4:06 pmI do intend to do that, yes.
Sweet!

Re: Queen Elisabeth Class Battleship

Posted: May 14th, 2021, 4:42 pm
by Hood
A very nice series.
I had a QE redux on my long-term list (my original drawings are very old) but can safely remove that now, these look pretty good.

Re: Queen Elisabeth Class Battleship

Posted: May 16th, 2021, 11:07 am
by eswube
Great looking series.

Re: Queen Elisabeth Class Battleship

Posted: May 17th, 2021, 9:38 am
by Karle94
I'm adding the rebuilds and partial rebuilds/modernisations.