Page 71 of 99
Re: FD scale Never Built Designs
Posted: August 19th, 2018, 8:17 am
by eswube
Very nice additions! I wasn't aware about these designs before.
Just one thing - these drawing IMHO could be improved a bit by clearing some excessive double black lines/pixels:
And it would be better if for the St. Andrew's cross on the tail You used very dark grey instead of actual black that's also used for the contours.
Re: FD scale Never Built Designs
Posted: August 19th, 2018, 1:49 pm
by Yqueleden
The double-line thing isn't easy on small planes, but then I'll modify it. Thanks for the advice.
Re: FD scale Never Built Designs
Posted: August 19th, 2018, 1:59 pm
by Yqueleden
odysseus1980 wrote: ↑August 19th, 2018, 2:30 am
Nice to see another little known aircraft.
Could you post a link for the HA-56, please?
There is very little information about Hispano Aviación's projects on the web and almost all in Spanish. The drawings are from the book "Hispano Suiza 1904-1972" by Manuel Lage, although they can be found in Secret project forum.
Greetings
Re: FD scale Never Built Designs
Posted: August 21st, 2018, 11:06 am
by Imperialist
France-AMX Chasseur de Chars (CDC)
Re: FD scale Never Built Designs
Posted: August 24th, 2018, 9:20 pm
by eswube
Nice, but I don't like the double-black-line-areas, esp. in the rear/engine area.
Re: FD scale Never Built Designs
Posted: August 25th, 2018, 11:48 am
by ABetterName
It seems to me like there's no precedent set for what is "too much" or "avoidable" when it comes to double black lines, given AFAIK there was no complaints about the MBT70?
Re: FD scale Never Built Designs
Posted: August 25th, 2018, 12:16 pm
by eswube
@ABetterName
Well, that matter is inherently a something to debate and, given the constraints of scale and style, there could be no "100% one and only true and proper way", but IMHO htere could be certain "tendencies".
In regards to the drawing in question - the green arrow points to place where double-black line is perfectly acceptable to me as is seems to be unavoidable and there seems to be no good alternative to it; the orange ones point to two places where I think it could be avoided, but I wouldn't make a big deal out of it, and the red ones point to places which I
really don't like.
For example, it seems to me that the 'thing' immediately aft of the turret is something like cover over the engine that extends over the hull - and to me it would look better if it was done with two parallel black lines with grey (color) line between them, instead of that mix. Same situation at the very back of the vehicle.
My rationale is that what we're doing are not, strictly speaking, technical plans, but representations of various vehicles
made using certain conventions, which occasionaly deliberately introduce certain inaccuracies in the interest of clarity and "clean-ness" of the drawing.
Obvious example of that - in SB scale - is the rule that makes all catwalks, stairways and the like are shown in 3-pixel format (contour-color-contour).
P.S. Yeah, I agree, it wouldn't be bad if there were several few more black pixels on MBT-70's tracks.
P.P.S. Earlier on this page I expressed similar concerns about double-black lines on Yqueleden's drawings. Here's a small sample I understand the idea of "clarity" and "clean-ness" comparing the original drawing (top) and "how it can be done otherwise in my humble opinion" (bottom).
Re: FD scale Never Built Designs
Posted: August 25th, 2018, 12:51 pm
by ABetterName
I think the engine deck has rather a few details which could be drawn better, including those vents.
Having looked at it closer now, I do agree that the double black lines around the back are avoidable and rather ugly.
Re: FD scale Never Built Designs
Posted: September 4th, 2018, 3:29 am
by Imperialist
USA-P-38E Lightning Assault Fighter
Armed with an automatic 75mm T-9 Cannon + 2 0.50 MG's
USA-P-38E Lightning Seaplane
USA-P-38E Lightning (Elongated Fuselage)
Re: FD scale Never Built Designs
Posted: September 6th, 2018, 10:40 am
by Kaiser
More Spanish planes, this time a regional airliner, the CASA 3000.
CASA 3000 with the livery that appeared on the concept arts by CASA and a blank livery.
I already posted it in the "begginers only" subforum, but I guess it is ok to have it here too. More info on the CASA 3000 here
http://shipbucket.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=18&t=8694
Edit:
User Toxic Loki made a
significantly improved version of my drawing and I decided to repaint it with the concept art livery: