Re: A new Illes Balears (Balearic Islands) AU in FD Scale
Posted: February 9th, 2021, 10:15 pm
This is a very nice Au. I really like what you did with the political map as well as the aircraft. I approve of this.
Official Forum
https://test.shipbucket.com/forums/
Ok, my main concern here is that there are now three aircraft in roughly similar size categories with this, the Defender, and the M-28. I think structure wise you're risking a proliferation of types that would have added costs that a small force might have a hard time bearing.indiajuliet wrote: ↑April 6th, 2021, 9:00 pm Pilatus PC-12: used for army liaison (officer transport, medevac and utility transport), and similar roles in air force service, plus regional VIP transport. The "Spectre" variant, similar to USAF U-28 Draco, is an option to modernise and enhance ISR capability of the FAIB.
Ok, I too enjoy the C-27J as a tactical airlifter. I would have proposed either this or a C-295, and I think the C-27J is a better fit. That said, if the Balaeric Islands are going to have in-flight refueling, I think that they might not own an independent tanker force. I could see them being reliant on NATO partner nations for tankers, or, if they absolutely needed an indigenous capability, a buddy-refueling kit for the C-27J based on those on the C-130 and A400M might be in order rather than the addition of another type into service. If you go with a KC-27J as it were, I think I'd place the hose on the pylon used on the MC-27J. This option would also probably result in a much larger C-27J force, which can be good for overall operability.indiajuliet wrote: ↑April 6th, 2021, 9:00 pmLeonardo (Alenia) C-27J Spartan: Another excellent base drawing from Darth Panda, the C-27J is a favourite of mine. This small-medium tactical transport airport is ideal for the small island nation of the Balearic Islands. The air force initially operates a fleet of 3 aircraft, with options for more. Based at Ariany, these aircraft are used to transport troops and equipment between the islands and in support of operations and exercises with allies overseas. The aircraft are equipped with air refuelling capability... KC-390 to come later. In times of emergency, the Spartan fleet provide humanitarian support and allow for the rapid mass movement of emergency personnel/equipment to the area in need. The aircraft can also be used in support of aerial forest firefighting and search and rescue operations.
Makes sense. I expect that most of the actual maintenance work is done by Setac, rather than by the air force.indiajuliet wrote: ↑April 6th, 2021, 9:00 pmAirbus A220 (former Bombardier CSeries): This replaces the venerable BAe 146 used for VIP transport. Although already operating a fleet of small bizjets and turboprop aircraft, these would often need to be accompanied by larger charter or commercial aircraft carrying supporting staff on overseas or domestic visits. It was therefore decided to opt to replace the BAe 146 instead of rely on commercial flights. The A220 / CSeries is an excellent aircraft, suitable for a variety of ranges from short regional up to transatlantic. This aircraft is configured as per the Airbus Corporate Jet TwoTwenty (ACJ220), but shares much commonality with the Setac airline fleet.
Thanks Glaciesfire. I was lucky to have many of your car models to start with.GLACIESFIRE wrote: ↑April 7th, 2021, 7:53 pm Just one word:
WOW O_o
PS I'm going to "steal" your Giulia station wagon!!!
Thanks Blackbuck. Thought it would make a nice change from battenburg becoming more widespread.
Possibly... it's a relatively small country, with a defence budget to match. I'm trying to keep realistic rather than go for biggest and best. I find that's an enjoyable part of the challenge, and have data from other countries to compare and calculate what may be a reasonable fleet. In terms of budget per capita, this would be a well funded European nation, but not quite at Israeli or small Middle East nation spending. I'll smarten up the defence structure and inventory that I have and share when I have some time - I should be working on my CEng application.Robert MacReady wrote: ↑April 7th, 2021, 12:24 pm Are there larger planes on the Balearic Islands, out of curiosity?
Thanks for the detailed feedback, Timothy. Always interesting to get another perspective.
You're welcome. I've commented before that in many ways, a well thought out smaller force can be more interesting than even what I end up sketching out for some of my ideas.indiajuliet wrote: ↑April 7th, 2021, 11:17 pm Thanks for the detailed feedback, Timothy. Always interesting to get another perspective.
Not directed at me directly, but I think that in a cost-benefit analysis, the existing 'fighter' is going to drive to the advanced trainer - rapidly. Maybe early model hawks and second-hand AMXes are planned to be replaced with M346s? I also don't see more than one or two squadrons available. Maybe a third in reserve.indiajuliet wrote: ↑April 7th, 2021, 11:17 pm But to answer your question (and linked to what Timothy posted), I was thinking of the largest aircraft being the Embraer KC-390 (only having 2) as a strategic transport, but to honest, that's probably too big an investment and capability beyond what is needed. A few more C-27J's would probably be wiser, but I'll think about it. Similar story with MPA capability, I was initially thinking of ATR-42/72, but downsized to M28 as a more economical solution and better suited to serve across a variety of roles too. Thinking about the fighter fleet is the biggest challenge... I still haven't quite decided on whether to have a small squadron of cheaper dedicated fighters (Gripen, Mirage?) or a bigger fleet of advanced trainers (Hawk, M346, MB339) with some dedicated to air defence and strike. Typhoon/Tornado/Rafale are out of the question (too expensive), but could Jaguar, AMX, Hawk 200 be suitable?
Would be interested to hear feedback.
An AEW version of the PC-24 or M28 combined with a retirement of the Defenders sounds like a good option - certainly if it allows expansion of the number of existing types.indiajuliet wrote: ↑April 7th, 2021, 11:17 pm On PC-12, yes I agree that it's another similar platform and probably wouldn't make sense for the Balearics. I just fancied seeing what it would look like to be honest, and thought it could make a good successor to Defender. I need to plan a proper in-service timeline for the air force, but I'm thinking that old Defenders could be replaced by a smaller number of Spectres, and the air force would lose it's AEW capability. Alternatively, I'm thinking I could put a side scanning AESA radar on top of a PC-24 (see Embraer have proposed Praetor 600 as compact bizjet AEW), unless it makes more sense to modify the M28 as a larger platform, to perform compact EW, ISR & AEW (albeit not as capable as much larger and more expensive aircraft).
I had suspected as much with the focus on Swiss and Italian aircraft. As for the tanker kits, I'd offer a suggestion of grabbing the pylons off of Little Bird's Preatorian, and the hose and drogue kit off of Yqueleden's KC-390indiajuliet wrote: ↑April 7th, 2021, 11:17 pm C-27J was an easy choice. I'm trying to think about politics too, and am aligning the Balearic Islands (from an aerospace industry perspective) with the UK and Italy, and certainly not being part of the 'EADS/Airbus club'. In line with real life now and the FCAS/Tempest programmes, I'm imagining two distinct European aerospace groups of France-Germany-Spain, and on the other hand UK-Italy-Sweden(-Netherlands maybe?) with the Balearic Islands AU aligned with the latter. I'm also steering away from Spanish aircraft (nothing personal!), as I think that in this AU, there would be some friction between the two countries (think much milder version of China + Taiwan, but don't want to be supporting each other's industries) - which rules out CN-235/C-295 as originally CASA aircraft. I think you're right about a sovereign tanker fleet being a step too far, but having buddy kits for C-27J's, good idea, thanks.
Sounds like you have it covered!indiajuliet wrote: ↑April 7th, 2021, 11:17 pm Yes, I do need to think about basic trainers. My initial thoughts were that they'd get aircraft from Italy or the UK (second hand, or a joint order?) - so SF260 or Tutor/Prefect. I've had some experience with Diamond aircraft (lovely cabin, better than any Cessna/Piper), so might be biased toward choosing them, DA20/40 for basic single and DA42 for twin engine training would be a good combination.